At the moment’s publish is about dry fasting. I’ve lined loads of different elements of intermittent fasting, together with suggestions round longer fasts, however recently I’ve gotten sufficient questions on this explicit angle that I assumed I’d handle it.
Dry fasting goes with out each meals and fluid. Meaning no espresso, no tea, no broth, and no water or liquid of any sort (besides the saliva you handle to supply). It’s an excessive sort of quick whose followers and practitioners are adamant that it could resolve severe well being points. However does it? Is it secure? And how much analysis is accessible on it?
The place Does the Concept of Therapeutic Dry Fasting Come From?
The principle proponent of dry fasting is a Russian physician named Sergei Filonov. Filonov continues to be practising from what I can inform, someplace within the Altai mountains that span Central Asia. I discovered a really tough English translation of his ebook—Dry Medical Fasting: Myths and Realities. Troublesome to learn in full as a result of it’s not an expert translation, however manageable in small chunks.
His primary thesis is that dry fasting creates a aggressive atmosphere between wholesome cells, unhealthy cells, and pathogens for a scarce useful resource: water. The dry quick acts as a robust selective strain, permitting the sturdy cells to outlive and the weak and harmful cells to die off. The top outcome, in line with Filonov, is that the immune system burns by way of the weak cells for vitality and to preserve water for the viable cells, resulting in a stronger organism total. He factors to how animals in nature will gap up in a secure, snug spot and take neither meals nor water when recovering from severe situations, sickness, or accidents that stop them from shifting round. However once they’re in a position to transfer whereas recovering from extra minor points, they’ll drink water and abstain from meals. I’m keen on this naturalistic line of thought, however I don’t know if the claims about animal habits throughout illness are true.
One other declare is that dry fasting hurries up fats loss relative to fasts that embrace water. There could also be one thing to this, as body fat is actually a source of “metabolic water”—inside water the physique can flip to when exogenous water is restricted. Burning 100 grams of fats produces 110 grams of water, whereas burning the identical quantity of carbohydrate produces simply 50 grams of water.
Are There Any Dry Fasting Research?
Sadly, we don’t have many long run dry fasting research. The truth is, we’ve one 5-day research in wholesome adults. For 5 days, ten wholesome adults kept away from consuming meals or consuming water. A number of physiological parameters have been tracked every day, together with body weight, kidney operate, coronary heart charge, electrolyte standing, and circumference of the waist, hip, neck, and chest.
Members misplaced weight (over 2 kilos a day) and inches off of assorted circumferences, together with waist, hip, neck, and chest. The drop in waist circumference was significantly giant—about eight centimeters by day 5. Blood strain, coronary heart charge, oxygen saturation, sodium and potassium ranges, creatinine, and urea all remained steady all through the research. Creatinine clearance—which could be a marker of muscle breakdown but in addition a normal artifact of fasting—elevated by as much as 167%.
Probably the most voluminous analysis we’ve on dry fasting is the Ramadan literature. Through the month of Ramadan, practising Muslims full a every day dry quick—from sunup to sunset—each single day. They eat no foods and drinks no fluids throughout daytime, which, within the nations the place Islam initially arose, run about 15-16 hours. These are shorter dry fasts than the 5-day quick detailed above.
What occurs to well being markers throughout Ramadan? Principally good issues.
A 15- or 16- hour dry quick isn’t very excessive, even within the sizzling climates of the Close to East. Two or three day-long dry fasts, significantly in sizzling climate, is one other factor totally. What works and is secure throughout 16 hours won’t be secure or efficient over three or 4 days.
I ponder if there’s a genetic part to dry fasting tolerance, too. Have populations who’ve spent hundreds of years in sizzling, dry, desert-like climates developed better genetic tolerance of durations with out water? I discover it possible, although I haven’t seen any genetic information by hook or by crook. It’s an fascinating factor to ponder.
Is Dry Fasting Protected?
Clearly, skipping water could be harmful. Whereas we’ve seen individuals go with out meals for as long as a year (offered you might have sufficient adipose tissue to burn, take nutritional vitamins and minerals, and are beneath medical supervision), going with out water is a riskier proposal. The quantity I’ve at all times heard was three weeks with out meals, three days with out water, although I’ve by no means actually seen it substantiated or sourced.
One cause I’m skeptical of “three days” as a tough and quick rule is that almost all circumstances of individuals dying of dehydration happen in dire circumstances. Individuals are misplaced out within the wilderness, mountain climbing round in useless looking for their means again to the trailhead. They’re thrown in jail after an evening out consuming and forgotten by the guards for 3 days. They’re spending 24 hours dancing in a tent within the desert on a number of psychoactive medication. These are excessive conditions that actually improve the necessity for water. Your water necessities will probably be a lot increased in case you’re mountain climbing round in sizzling climate bathing in stress-induced cortisol and adrenaline, or dancing exhausting for hours on finish. Very hardly ever will we hear of individuals getting down to abstain from water on goal for medical advantages, water available in case issues go south, and ending up dehydrated. A part of the reason being that only a few individuals are dry fasting, so the pool of potential proof is miniscule. I think about this final group could have extra leeway.
Nonetheless, in case you’re going to attempt dry fasting, you need to take some primary precautions.
6 Precautions To Take When Dry Fasting
1. Get Your Physician’s Okay
Positive, most will probably be skeptical at greatest, however I’d nonetheless advise not skipping this step—significantly if in case you have a well being situation or take any form of medicine. Diuretics (typically used for blood strain administration), for one instance, add one other layer to this image.
2. No Train
Keep away from something extra intense than strolling. For one, the hypohydration will predispose you to middling outcomes, growing cortisol and decreasing testosterone. Two, the hypohydration might progress quickly to dehydration. If you happen to’re going to train throughout a dry quick, “break” the quick with water first after which practice.
three. Hold It Transient
Sure, there was the 5-day research, however these individuals have been being monitored by medical doctors each single day. I’d say 16-24 hours is a secure higher restrict and doubtless offers a lot of the advantages (as Ramadan literature reveals). Any longer, purchaser beware. (And, after all, be sure you get totally hydrated in between any dry fasts you would possibly do.)
four. Quick Whereas You Sleep
Ramadan-style in all probability isn’t ultimate from a pure physiological standpoint. The size (16 hours) is nice, however the consuming schedule is just not. Those that observe Ramadan fasting ritual typically get up earlier than dawn to slot in meals. They might keep up late to eat extra. They fall asleep in a well-fed state, by no means fairly benefiting from the eight hours of “free” fasting time sleep often offers (and, after all, that’s not what their fasting follow is about). For a health-motivated dry quick, however, you need to make the most of it.
5. Take Climate Into Account
Sizzling, humid climate will typically trigger essentially the most water loss. Chilly, dry climate will trigger the least. Alter your dry fasting period accordingly.
6. Pay attention To Your Physique
I’ve mentioned this 1,000,000 instances, however it’s particularly price saying right here. If you happen to’re not feeling nicely throughout the dry quick, hearken to your intuition fairly than your agenda. (And don’t start a dry quick whenever you’re ailing. That ought to go with out saying.) That is an elective software. There are a whole lot of different methods to serve your well being and well-being. Don’t lose the forest by way of the timber since you’re drawn to a follow that feels extra radical. Method it well, however let your physique’s instinct be the ultimate arbiter.
That’s it for me. I haven’t completed any dry fasting, not on goal not less than, and I’m not significantly concerned about it for myself, however I am concerned about your experiences. Do any of you do dry fasting? What have you ever observed? What do you advocate?
As at all times, if in case you have any questions, direct them down under. Thanks for studying!
Mascioli SR, Bantle JP, Freier EF, Hoogwerf BJ. Artifactual elevation of serum creatinine level due to fasting. Arch Intern Med. 1984;144(eight):1575-6.
Fernando HA, Zibellini J, Harris RA, Seimon RV, Sainsbury A. Effect of Ramadan Fasting on Weight and Body Composition in Healthy Non-Athlete Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Vitamins. 2019;11(2)
Fahrial syam A, Suryani sobur C, Abdullah M, Makmun D. Ramadan Fasting Decreases Body Fat but Not Protein Mass. Int J Endocrinol Metab. 2016;14(1):e29687.
Aliasghari F, Izadi A, Gargari BP, Ebrahimi S. The Effects of Ramadan Fasting on Body Composition, Blood Pressure, Glucose Metabolism, and Markers of Inflammation in NAFLD Patients: An Observational Trial. J Am Coll Nutr. 2017;36(eight):640-645.
Unalacak M, Kara IH, Baltaci D, Erdem O, Bucaktepe PG. Effects of Ramadan fasting on biochemical and hematological parameters and cytokines in healthy and obese individuals. Metab Syndr Relat Disord. 2011;9(2):157-61.
Saleh SA, El-kemery TA, Farrag KA, et al. Ramadan fasting: relation to atherogenic risk among obese Muslims. J Egypt Public Well being Assoc. 2004;79(5-6):461-83.
Gueldich H, Zghal F, Borji R, Chtourou H, Sahli S, Rebai H. The effects of Ramadan intermittent fasting on the underlying mechanisms of force production capacity during maximal isometric voluntary contraction. Chronobiol Int. 2019;36(5):698-708.
Shephard RJ. Ramadan and sport: minimizing effects upon the observant athlete. Sports activities Med. 2013;43(12):1217-41.